Should I save my money to get the Revlon colorstay liquid eyeliner or just opt for NYC's cheaper version?

I'm a teen w/o an allowance or job, end of story. I've never tried liquid liner except like once that ended badly lol. But i'm sick of smudging and fading pencil liner.





Is NYC's liner as cheap as its priced? Or should I pay three times more for Revlon's?





thank you :))Should I save my money to get the Revlon colorstay liquid eyeliner or just opt for NYC's cheaper version?
i had the revlon colorstay and it was one of my favorites!Should I save my money to get the Revlon colorstay liquid eyeliner or just opt for NYC's cheaper version?
I like the applicator from the Revlon Color Stay better than the NYC one, and sometimes the NYC liquid liner tends to flake. I'd go for the Color Stay. Good luck!
NYC liquid liner was my first liquid liner and I loved it. I bought the wrong color the first time (Pearl black), but it still looked good. It had pretty good staying power for its price and overall I liked it. I'm not a fan of Revlon Colorstay eyeliner in general because I've had bad experiences with the Colorstay pencil liner, and I heard that the liquid liner was barely better. If you want to stick to your budget and save money, get the NYC, and if you want to go a little higher try the Almay liner or the L'Oreal liquid liners (those are good!)
I've always used Revlon colorstay it works better than NYC. Also you sometimes with cheap liquid eyeliner you can peel off the eyeliner.





All pencil eyeliners fade and smudge that's why you have to do touch up's. You can also try using Revlon eyeliner works good and stays on long.
I think you should buy cheaper makeup it works better i buy cheap make up buy nyc makeup